Test number 3 completed today.
This was with the Bluefusion 50W panel connected directly the the CTEK250SE installed in my van, not using the controller that was supplied with the solar panels.
To start with I had to make up some cables as follows:
This enables me to connect the original controller to the panels or to disconnect the original controller and connect via the extension cable to the CTEK, thus giving me the flexibility to connect to other stuff if i need to (e.g. direct to the Starter battery or to one of my motorcycle batteries).
- I cut the cable between the solar panel and the solar controller supplied with it and inserted a pair of powerpole connectors on each of the cut ends
- I made a new extension cable from 14AWG red/black and terminated each end in a pair of powerpole connectors
- I made a short cable from 14AWG cable terminated in a pair of powerpole connectors on one end and M8 eyelets on the other. This connects to the CTEK
The cables look like this:
View attachment 71894
Connected to the original controller:
View attachment 71895
Bypassing the original controller:
View attachment 71896
And the short connector added to the CTEK: I then just poked the connector through so it is easily accessible from under the front of the drivers seat.
View attachment 71897
So with the cabling made up I started the test in the same way as the previous two.
I connected the panel a little before 7AM this morning and laid it on the roof. At this time there is no sun on the van.
BM2 reading from before connecting up:
View attachment 71898
The sun gets on to the van around 9.30AM. You will see in the trace below that there was a very small charge up until around 9.30 and from then it increased significantly and continued to climb pretty much all day. This looks much less peaky than the two previous tests. I moved the panel onto the front of the van up against the windscreen but I can’t remember exactly when. I think it was where the slight dip is at 14:30ish. It was obviously catching more light from then on as the graph gets a little steeper.
Unfortunately I had to go out in the van at 3PM hence the test ending then. I’d have like to have got to the point where the CTEK started to trickle charge the starter battery but I didn’t get that far.
View attachment 71899
At 3PM I took my dog for a walk on the beach (I live very close). While I was there I thought I’d stick the panel on again but this time inside the windscreen. Later in the day, laid flatter and behind the glass so probably not the optimal setup but worth a go and a rel life situation. This is the trace extended to include that period. The two high peaks are the drive there and the drive back, the flat section where it is around 13.5V is the period the panel was connected up in this way:
View attachment 71901
As I said, I’d like to have got to the point where the CTEK started to trickle charge the starter battery but other than that I am very pleased with the results.
I set out to test whether a cheapish portable solar panel would be capable of charging starter or leisure batteries for periods where the van is not in use or whilst remote and parked up. I’m happy that it will do this given decent sunshine. What I have learned is that the CTEK appears to be the better way of charging the leisure battery. I’d like to test the reverse charge of the starter battery but will need to find a suitable window where I can leave the van for longer to do this. A higher output panel would obviously do this more quickly but i think for my personal needs what I have works.
Thanks @Dellmassive. I too noticed the same thing when i connected up the solar cable. I didn’t fit the CTEK myself so I had already added this to my list of things to do. I’m equally not sure why it is on a separate earth point to the battery. You can just make out the battery earth point just at the top of the CTEK. I would have connected them both to the same point. I just need to get a short bit of suitable gauge cable and crips to match.side thread: . . . . . . . . . . (@Big.mac )
i just noticed something on your D250SE pic . . . . the ground cable looks a bit thin?
View attachment 72167
book says 12AWG or 4mm"2 or thicker? (but can tell what size it is from the pic? but it looks too small/thin?)
View attachment 72164
not sure from the pic but it looks like it goes to the bolt at the bottom of the pic? on yellow crimps?
might be worth fitting a nice beefy fat cable to replace the thin one?
on DC-DC units i normally fit the same Gauge cable as the positive battery feeds.
Remember current flows through that ground terminal as well as the battery in/out.
Today's test:
BlueFusion 120W kit
a continuation of : Mobile Solar Panels ? . . . - How I Did It -
But this time on the Van.
Its a folded panel like the 50W version,
View attachment 72146
checking the spec we have:
so 6.67A max (Imp) (7.20A ISC Max) - so thats enough under the 10A i like to use for a 12V socket.
View attachment 72147
next job to swap out the supplied crock-clamps for a 12v socket lead.
"heres one i prepared earlier" - lol.
its a 16AWG 5mtr 12v plug/socket extension lead.
View attachment 72148
i cut it down to about 4mtrs and checked it was fused . . .
View attachment 72149
then just swapped over the screw terminals, (keeping the other lead for another day)
View attachment 72150
Next it was out to the van, its too big for the dash so i popped it on the roof long ways . . .
View attachment 72151View attachment 72157
and fixed in place with a couple of strong magnets . . .
View attachment 72152View attachment 72153
cable run . .
View attachment 72154
plugged into the starter battery socket . . . .
View attachment 72155
which brought the unit into life . . .
View attachment 72156
*********************************************************
weather wise we are looking good for today:
View attachment 72158
from the pics you can see the tree shading and the building that shades the van and panel in that location.
the current battery states are @ 800hrs :
starter battery:
View attachment 72159View attachment 72160
and remembering the DC-DC charger (Currently Redarc) will "Auto VSR" when the starter is up to 13v and start charging the Aux battery
here is the Aux battery :
View attachment 72161View attachment 72162
TBC later . . . . . . . .
1315hrs and something is not right.
for 120W i should be smashing it . . . . but the readings are very low, below 13v still... (no auto VSR yet?)
View attachment 72188
i checked with a amp meter and had a jumping reading from 3A to 0.6A . . . something not right here.
View attachment 72190View attachment 72191
to test things i swapped out the controller for a Victron 75/15.. . . . . then BOOM !
TBC . . . . PIC LIMIT . . . .
The "-"-terminal on the CTEK D250SE is just the ground "reference", so no significant current going through that one (just reference+small current to drive the electronics). All the "powerful" things are happening between "+"-terminals and all the the energy sources and sinks share common ground at chassis.i just noticed something on your D250SE pic . . . . the ground cable looks a bit thin?
For anyone thats interested i thought i would have a look inside the EPEVER LS1024EU . . . .continued from above: . . . . .
to test things i swapped out the controller for a Victron 75/15. MPPT . . . . . then BOOM !
View attachment 72198
straight up to 13v . . . . so we know the panel is good.
View attachment 72193
the BM2 shows an immediate rise in voltage . .
View attachment 72195
and the victron shows the stats . .
View attachment 72196View attachment 72197
So the panels good.
whats the issues here? . . . the controller? . . . or just PWM in general?
so next i swapped out the PMW for the other PWM i had on the 50W kit . . .
View attachment 72199
i got the same result . . . . . 12.8v . . . but not above the 13v i was looking for . . .
View attachment 72200
ok so it must be something to do with the controller throttling the power from the panel . . . .
so next was to try a different PWM controller . . . . this time the new Renogy PWM . . .
View attachment 72201
wired in . . .
View attachment 72202
then BOOM again !!!
4.9A going to battery and voltage rising again.. . . . . !!
The Renogy PWM has been on for 5mins. . . . . just look at the readings !!!!!!
14.4V . . . . .boosting the starter !
above 13v so the DC-DC has kicked in
and now charging the Aux battery too.
View attachment 72203
View attachment 72204
*********************
Renogy Wanderer Li 30A 12V PWM Negative Ground Charge Controller Compatible with Lithium, Sealed, Gel, and Flooded batteries and Renogy Bluetooth Module: Amazon.co.uk: Garden & Outdoors
Shop Renogy Wanderer Li 30A 12V PWM Negative Ground Charge Controller Compatible with Lithium, Sealed, Gel, and Flooded batteries and Renogy Bluetooth Module. Free delivery on eligible orders of £20 or more.amzn.to
Renogy Voyager - 20A Negative PWM Waterproof Charge Controller w/LCD Display and LED Bar
View attachment 72206
.
so we know that the included solar PWM controller is a cheapy for the price of the kit . . . . . but it seems that above 50W it just doesn't cut it.
here I've shown two examples of the very same panel giving twice to three times the through put as the LS1024EU.
first example was the Victron 75/15 MPPT.
second was the Renogy 20A PWM.
Moral of the story is : - Any Solar panels performance will be increased with a decent solar controller.
and,
you get what you pay for, so a cheap kit = cheap controller.
the good thing is its easy to swap out the controller. =]
.
Test ended @ 2030hrs due to getting the van ready for work . . .
The 120w panel was left connected to the Renogy for the remainder of the day . . .
you can see the Renogy done a stellar job Boosting the battery from around 1445hrs
then dropped to float @ 1645hrs
and still holding 13v untill 1900hrs.
View attachment 72244
starter battery @ 2017hrs :
View attachment 72245
lets look at the AUX battery . . . . we are expecting it to be charged via the Redarc Auto VSR DC-DC when the starter battery reaches 13v and over.
as expected the AUX started charging at 1315hrs (The Victron 75/15 was connected at that point)
and was kept at float all the way untill 200hrs ish. (Renogy PWM)
View attachment 72246
the AUX battery final voltage @ 12.61v
View attachment 72247
and so you can see the results together here is the BM3 readout . . .
you can clearly see that the supplied PWM controller was keeping the starter at around 12.8v, which was not high enough for the Redarc DC-DC to kick in. . .
as soon as we swapped over the controller, Victron, then Renogy you can see the panel coming into life and charging bothe batterys with at least 5A charge current as witnessed on the Victron App.
View attachment 72248View attachment 72249
Conclusion . . .
The Panel is great and will deliver the power down to low light levels with a decent controller.
The supplied controller is not so great at getting the most out of the panels at varing conditions.
even though the controller spec states 14.4v boost, 13.8v float
View attachment 72253
im still unsure why the LS1024EU performed so badly on this occasion. . . . . and as we see from the results above the Victron & Renogy controllers well out performed it using the same panel, same van, same cables, same battery, same everything.
Possible faulty unit i though, which is why i swapped them over . . .?
but the second LS1024EU gave similar results.
in the end swapping the controller out for a known good worked great. . . .
remember this is for the 120W panel . . . . so maybe the higher amps was causing a problem?
***********************
For now i think i will leave the Renogy PWM connected to the panel.
View attachment 72252
following on from the BlueFusion 120W saga and included solar controller . . . .continued from above: . . . . .
to test things i swapped out the controller for a Victron 75/15. MPPT . . . . . then BOOM !
View attachment 72198
straight up to 13v . . . . so we know the panel is good.
View attachment 72193
the BM2 shows an immediate rise in voltage . .
View attachment 72195
and the victron shows the stats . .
View attachment 72196View attachment 72197
So the panels good.
whats the issues here? . . . the controller? . . . or just PWM in general?
so next i swapped out the PMW for the other PWM i had on the 50W kit . . .
View attachment 72199
i got the same result . . . . . 12.8v . . . but not above the 13v i was looking for . . .
View attachment 72200
ok so it must be something to do with the controller throttling the power from the panel . . . .
so next was to try a different PWM controller . . . . this time the new Renogy PWM . . .
View attachment 72201
wired in . . .
View attachment 72202
then BOOM again !!!
4.9A going to battery and voltage rising again.. . . . . !!
The Renogy PWM has been on for 5mins. . . . . just look at the readings !!!!!!
14.4V . . . . .boosting the starter !
above 13v so the DC-DC has kicked in
and now charging the Aux battery too.
View attachment 72203
View attachment 72204
*********************
Renogy Wanderer Li 30A 12V PWM Negative Ground Charge Controller Compatible with Lithium, Sealed, Gel, and Flooded batteries and Renogy Bluetooth Module: Amazon.co.uk: Garden & Outdoors
Shop Renogy Wanderer Li 30A 12V PWM Negative Ground Charge Controller Compatible with Lithium, Sealed, Gel, and Flooded batteries and Renogy Bluetooth Module. Free delivery on eligible orders of £20 or more.amzn.to
Renogy Voyager - 20A Negative PWM Waterproof Charge Controller w/LCD Display and LED Bar
View attachment 72206
.
so we know that the included solar PWM controller is a cheapy for the price of the kit . . . . . but it seems that above 50W it just doesn't cut it.
here I've shown two examples of the very same panel giving twice to three times the through put as the LS1024EU.
first example was the Victron 75/15 MPPT.
second was the Renogy 20A PWM.
Moral of the story is : - Any Solar panels performance will be increased with a decent solar controller.
and,
you get what you pay for, so a cheap kit = cheap controller.
the good thing is its easy to swap out the controller. =]
.
Test ended @ 2030hrs due to getting the van ready for work . . .
The 120w panel was left connected to the Renogy for the remainder of the day . . .
you can see the Renogy done a stellar job Boosting the battery from around 1445hrs
then dropped to float @ 1645hrs
and still holding 13v untill 1900hrs.
View attachment 72244
starter battery @ 2017hrs :
View attachment 72245
lets look at the AUX battery . . . . we are expecting it to be charged via the Redarc Auto VSR DC-DC when the starter battery reaches 13v and over.
as expected the AUX started charging at 1315hrs (The Victron 75/15 was connected at that point)
and was kept at float all the way untill 200hrs ish. (Renogy PWM)
View attachment 72246
the AUX battery final voltage @ 12.61v
View attachment 72247
and so you can see the results together here is the BM3 readout . . .
you can clearly see that the supplied PWM controller was keeping the starter at around 12.8v, which was not high enough for the Redarc DC-DC to kick in. . .
as soon as we swapped over the controller, Victron, then Renogy you can see the panel coming into life and charging bothe batterys with at least 5A charge current as witnessed on the Victron App.
View attachment 72248View attachment 72249
Conclusion . . .
The Panel is great and will deliver the power down to low light levels with a decent controller.
The supplied controller is not so great at getting the most out of the panels at varing conditions.
even though the controller spec states 14.4v boost, 13.8v float
View attachment 72253
im still unsure why the LS1024EU performed so badly on this occasion. . . . . and as we see from the results above the Victron & Renogy controllers well out performed it using the same panel, same van, same cables, same battery, same everything.
Possible faulty unit i though, which is why i swapped them over . . .?
but the second LS1024EU gave similar results.
in the end swapping the controller out for a known good worked great. . . .
remember this is for the 120W panel . . . . so maybe the higher amps was causing a problem?
***********************
For now i think i will leave the Renogy PWM connected to the panel.
View attachment 72252
Mine isn’t fused. I looked at the CTEK manual and that didn’t require a fuse so I didn’t use one.Do you guys put a fuse between your solar panel and MPPT? I have fused pretty much every other +ve connection i have on the van, but lots of people say due to how solar works you don't need this and you want as few connections between the panel and the MPPT as possible.... I would have thought it should still have a 20A fuse on the +ve cable, but what are you guys doing? If you are fusing it, what type of fuses have you gone for?
Replaced the ground cable on the CTEK today. While i had the seat out I stuck the clip on ammeter onto the ground cable and it looks to me as if there is current flow through it. Anyways it’s sorted now with a 16mm cable so I won’t need to worry either way.The "-"-terminal on the CTEK D250SE is just the ground "reference", so no significant current going through that one (just reference+small current to drive the electronics). All the "powerful" things are happening between "+"-terminals and all the the energy sources and sinks share common ground at chassis.